How to Write a Critical Response Essay

How to Write a Critical Response Essay

Usually, as part of the curriculum, students need to write various kinds of essays from time to time. However, some encounter challenges when they try to do a response paper assignment or write a response paper example. This begs the question, why do students find it difficult to write a critical response essay.

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Assignment on
How to Write a Critical Response Essay
Just from $13/Page
Order Now

In this article, we try to debunk this misconception and provide a guide on how to write a critical essay. If you are very short on time, however, and would like to quickly learn how to write a critical inquiry paper or better yet have an expert do your personal critical response essay, then head over to myhomeworkwriters.com.

My Homework Writers has been the best essay help service on the web for years. They have an awesome team of experts capable of handling all your essay needs at pocket-friendly prices. To assure you of their outstanding quality, they can provide you a critical writing sample or a critical essay example. Also, make sure you check out their guide on how to write a critical response essay.

how to write a critical response essay

What Is a Critical Response Essay?

Critical essays are types of writing meant to evaluate, interpret, or analyze specific kinds of literary works or media forms. This type of paper is quite common among academic audiences and is particularly useful in supporting arguments made by creators of literary works or media.

The ultimate goal of critical essays is to enable students or writers to nurture their skills in critical writing. Also, these papers aim to provide the audience with the writer’s interpretation or thought-provoking explanations regarding the media under critique.

Nowadays, it is also very common for people authoring critical analysis to express their thoughts on different themes in films or books on very broad spectrums. Critical writing particularly needs the exemplary ability to assess the message the original creator or author was trying to convey to the original audience. A critical essay should explain this initial message to the new audience concisely and less ambiguously.

Before answering the question “how to write a critical response essay,” it is important to understand the purpose of writing a critical paper, to begin with.

Goals of Critical Writing

Some primary objectives of critical writing include:

  • Providing an objective perspective of the original creator’s or author’s work
  • Offering a thorough analysis of how consistent the original work is
  • Thoroughly assessing the original creator’s ability to support and maintain their primary concepts or arguments
  • Presenting a contrast of the strengths and weaknesses of the media in question
  • Criticizing the original work of the creator or writer in question

How Do You Write a Critical Essay Example?

If you are new to writing critical essays, then perhaps you may not know how to write a thesis for a critical analysis essay or even an entire essay. Many people, more so students can refer to essay examples on specific topics to grasp critical writing. It helps form a basis on how to write essays on their own.

To create a useful critical essay example for yourself and other students in a similar position to yours, follow the steps below.

Determine What the Assignment Requires

Whenever students begin working on an assignment whose requirements they are unfamiliar with, they usually set themselves up for failure. It is, therefore, mandatory that you understand all the assignment’s details and seek clarification if necessary.

Develop an In-Depth Understanding of Your Source Material

The source material for your assignment may come in different forms, e.g., films, books, pieces of art, or other media. To write a critical paper that deeply analyses your source material, you must understand it well enough.

Take Notes When Assessing Your Source Material

This is an aspect many students overlook when figuring out how to write a critical response essay. Taking concise notes when assessing any source material is an ingredient to successfully writing a critical paper.

Uncover Major Patterns in the Work You Critique

After reviewing the media you are working with, always identify any patterns, problems, or challenges that exist. This will help you uncover key concepts or issues that you would have otherwise not identified.

Discover Solutions to the Challenges

Lastly, provide solutions to the patterns or problems found in the previous step.

If you need assistance on “how to write a critical response essay,” head over to myhomeworkwriters.com, the best essay help service on the web.

How Do You Write a Critical Analysis Essay?

The process of writing a critical analysis essay begins with examining relevant primary sources. Before you begin any actual writing, you should get yourself up to speed with the subject at hand. Your primary source may be a book, a film, an article, or even a piece of art. Gather as much information as you can on your subject. When analyzing the primary source, always take notes highlighting the main points that will form the foundation of your paper.

After thoroughly analyzing the primary source, try summarizing your findings. Using your notes, create a structure for your essay. Formulate an opinion, i.e., whether you agree or disagree with the opinions of the author. Make sure you can back your arguments with substantial evidence.

how to write a critical response essay

When you have finally gathered all the material necessary to write your essay, all you have to do now is some actual writing. Generally, this is what students expect when they ask the question “how to write a critical response essay.”

  1. First, create a rough draft of the critical response essay.
  2. Go through your draft and make any necessary edits.
  3. Proofread your work, write a final version, and edit it if need be.
  4. Check your work for punctuation and grammatical errors and plagiarism.
  5. If your assignment requires it, write a bibliography page.

What Are the Steps to Write a Critical Response Essay?

To answer the question “how to write a critical response essay,” practically, we should break everything down into four major steps.


  • Understand the assignment and all its requirements.
  • Critically evaluate the primary source.
  • Take relevant notes during the evaluation.
  • Review the notes to discover any issues or patterns.

Conduct Research

  • If necessary, find relevant secondary sources.
  • Evaluate your secondary sources for credibility purposes.
  • Go through your research.
  • Take notes.

Writing the Essay

  • Develop a tentative thesis statement.
  • Consult your research notes to develop an essay outline.
  • Start your essay with a captivating sentence that dives straight into the topic.
  • Provide background information
  • Discuss specific elements of the text using body paragraphs.
  • Conclude your essay

Revise Your Essay

How to Write a Critical Response Essay

The goal of writing critical essays is analyzing books, articles, events, films, or works of art and supporting all arguments made with relevant details. Successfully writing a critical response essay requires you to follow a methodical approach.

Preparation for Writing the Critical Essay

Like other things in life, writing a critical essay requires prior preparation to achieve success. We can summarize the preparation phase for how to write a critical response essay in the following steps.

Understand the Assignment and All Its Requirements

As soon as your instructor assigns you a paper, read its guidelines, carefully highlighting everything ambiguous. Ask your instructor for clarification on unclear instructions or if you do not understand the entire assignment altogether.

Critically Evaluate Your Primary Sources

Critical essay assignments require students to evaluate different kinds of works. To successfully perform any critical analysis, you must familiarize yourself with the primary source. If your primary source is a book, read it inside out to understand it deeply.

Take Notes As You Evaluate Your Material

Taking notes as you go on is necessary for remembering vital elements of your primary source. It will also help in critical thinking. As you go through your text, ask yourself some important questions like what the text is about, what are its main ideas, what puzzles you about the text, what is its purpose and does it achieve its purpose.

Identify Patterns and Issues from Your Notes

After reading the text and taking relevant notes, go through your notes to identify any patterns or issues that may stand out. Develop meaningful solutions to the issues you identify. The solutions you provide should help build a focus for the essay. However, note that at this point, you probably do not have a solid argument about the primary source.

Conduct Your Research

The research phase is necessary for finding relevant material to build a foundation for the entire essay. To conduct adequate research, follow these steps.

how to write a critical response essay

Find Relevant Select Secondary Sources If Necessary

If your essay’s guidelines require you to include sources, then you will need to conduct some research. Refer to the assignment guidelines or consult your instructor if you have questions on what sources are appropriate for the assignment.

Evaluate Your Sources for Credibility

It is necessary that you only use trustworthy sources. Failure to do so can ruin your reputation as an author. To ensure you only use trustworthy sources, refer to your library’s database. Some considerations to make when determining the credibility of your sources are:

The Authors and Their Credentials

Only rely on sources that mention the authors and their credentials. The credentials should mention why the authors are competent in their respective subjects. Sources that do not cite the authors or do not highlight their credentials may not be credible. For instance, you may consider an article written by a medical doctor regarding medical conditions to be a trustworthy source.


Reflect on whether the authors have conducted adequate research on the topic. Check the bibliography page provided in the text. If there are a handful or no sources at all, then it may be untrustworthy.


Think about whether the author’s account of the subject matter is objective. How often does the author’s argument seem one-sided? Does the author regularly dismiss opposing concerns? If such occurrences are regular, then your source may be biased. However, literary criticism may be an exception to this since it is inherently full of bias.

Publication Date

Determine whether the source provides up-to-date information. This is particularly useful for scientific subjects since the field of science is very dynamic.

Information The Source Provides

If, for whatever reasons, you still question the credibility of a particular source, cross-check the information it provides against trustworthy sources. You can conclude that a source is not good enough for your essay if the information in the source contradicts that of the trustworthy sources.

Go through Your Research

After gathering all the relevant sources, it is now time to go through them. Use a similar approach to reading or analyzing the primary sources. Read your research multiple times and ensure you understand it fully.

Take Notes

As you analyze your research, highlight any significant passages. Proper highlighting will enable you easily refer back to important points. Also, jot down any important information in your notes.

When you quote a source word for word, clearly indicated by adding quotation marks and providing details about the source. Some important details to include are the author’s name, book title, publisher, page number, and year of publishing.

Write the Essay

After gathering all the relevant material and developing this a proper outline to follow, it is now time to do some actual writing. This section adequately answers the question “how to write a critical response essay.”

how to write a critical response essay

Create a Tentative Thesis

After thoroughly going through the primary sources and constructing relevant ideas, you should be able to develop a thesis statement. An effective thesis statement expresses the paper’s primary focus while stating an arguable claim.

In most cases, it may come in handy to develop a multi-sentence thesis statement. This involves the first sentence providing a general idea, and the second refining it for more specificity.

Ensure your thesis statement provides adequate details. Therefore, avoid vaguely mentioning that something is “effective” and instead mention why it is effective. Place the thesis statement at the end of the first paragraph unless the instructor says otherwise.

Develop an Outline for Your Essay from the Research Notes

As a rule of thumb, creating an outline before writing a draft for the essay will help organize your thoughts much better. Your outline can be scant or rich in detail, depending on your preference. However, keep in mind that the more information you provide in the outline, the more ready material you will have for your paper.

Start Your Essay With A Captivating Sentence That Dives Straight Into The Topic

The introduction of your paper should kick off the discussion for your topic. To figure out what to include in the introduction, reflect on what you intend to discuss in the essay. Bear in mind that the introduction should capture your essay’s main idea and provide a preview to the rest of the paper.

Other excellent techniques for opening essays include using evocative details that link to larger ideas. In addition, you can begin by mentioning a compelling statistic or posing a question that your essay should answer.

Provide Background Information to Guide the Readers

Providing adequate information on the topic’s context or background is essential for guiding readers through the essay. Determine what the readers will have to know to fully comprehend the entire essay then provide such information within the first paragraph.

Your background information should build-up to the thesis statement. The information to provide in the first paragraph varies depending on the type of assignment. For instance:

  • If writing about a film, include a brief synopsis.
  • Provide the names of the author, their work, and a concise summary of the plot if writing about a book.
  • Include a brief description for the readers if writing about still images, e.g., paintings.

Discuss Specific Elements of the Text in the Body Paragraphs

Instead of discussing multiple aspects of the text in one paragraph, ensure individual body paragraphs focus on particular aspects of the text. Your discussion of these aspects ought to contribute to validating your thesis.

Generally, provide the following in each body paragraph:

  • A claim at the start of the paragraph.
  • Support the claim made with at least a single example from the primary source.
  • Reinforce the claim by supporting it with at least one example from the secondary source.

Conclude the Essay

Develop a concise conclusion that emphasizes what you have tried to reveal to your audience about the topic. Before writing a conclusion, take time and reflect on everything you have written in the paper. From this reflection, determine how best you can end the essay.

There are various excellent options for ending essays. These options may help you decide on the best way to format your conclusion. For instance, you may decide to:

  • Review and summarize the main concepts about the topic
  • Explain how the subject concerns the readers
  • Reveal how your narrow subject applies to broader observations or themes
  • Provide further exploration on the subject
  • Call your readers to action
  • Present new questions that the essay introduces

Recent Blog Posts

No recent articles to show.

Other Blog Posts

What are the key elements of an essay

You may clearly understand what an essay is and have had the experience of writing a number. However, it is […]

Feb 25th, 2022

How to write a research paper fast

The day inevitably comes; you need to submit your assignment. You have been procrastinating on writing your paper until the […]

Feb 24th, 2022

220+ best humanities research paper topics

Choosing a paper topic can be a daunting task for any assignment. A student may face agony trying to come […]

Feb 24th, 2022

How to write a media analysis essay

The media is an integral part of modern society. Think of what would happen to the world if there were […]

Feb 23rd, 2022

Great tricks on how to write a hypothesis in 2022

A hypothesis is a statement that can be proven by scientific research. It proves the theory of action and reaction, […]

Feb 22nd, 2022

How to get better at math

Math is not difficult. However, it is complex and tough compared to other subjects and requires a little bit more […]

Feb 22nd, 2022