fbpx

Is Consciousness a Fundamental Property

It is said that David Chalmers thinks that consciousness is a fundamental property. I want you to think about whether or not that is true.

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Assignment on
Is Consciousness a Fundamental Property
Just from $13/Page
Order Now

Before you get started, there’s a few concepts I want you to understand. They are “mass,” “wetness,” “emergence,” and “fundamentality.”

Mass is that property of matter that, among other things, gives it weight. (Actually, there’s three kinds of mass, but they’re equivalent, so I’m ignoring the distinction.) Matter (apparantly) has mass because atoms contain “Higgs bosons,” and these Higgs bosons carry mass with them, so that everything made of atoms will have mass. The more higgs bosons in an object, the more mass, and therefore the more weight an object will have.

Wetness is that slight tendency of water to stick to things. Throw a bucket of water on a friend. You will notice that while most of the water runs off him on to the floor, some of it sticks to him. In particular, water sticks to surfaces, so clothing with a lot of surface area, like a wool sweater, will hold a lot of water, while clothing with minimal surface area, like plastic raincoat, will hold comparitively little water. Wetness is caused by the fact that water molecules (made from one atom of oxygen and two of hydrogen) are weakly attractive to each other and to other particles. Hence small masses of water will stick to whatever they touch while larger masses overcome the attraction and flow away.Is Consciousness a Fundamental Property

Emergence is when a property only shows up in the universe when certain other conditions are met. For instance, wetness only appears in the universe when there are weakly attractive molecules, like water molecules, that can stick to surfaces. Oxygen molecules do not have wetness. Hydrogen molecules do not have wetness. But when oxygen and hydrogen are combined to make water, then wetness emerges from the combination. If you think about it, TONS of properties are emergent. Just think of any property that you have to put stuff together to get, and that’s an emergent property.

Fundamentality or “being fundamental” happens when a property is just there in certain objects, and doesn’t have to be made by combining things. Wetness is not a fundamental property precisely because it emerges from the combination of hydrogen and oxygen in water. Mass, on the other hand is a fundamental property because, basically, it’s just there. You really can’t get rid of it. Sure, you can take the Higgs bosons out of particles (theoretically) but you can’t get the mass out of the Higgs boson. You’re stuck with it. That’s what makes it fundamental.

Apparantly, Chalmers believes (among other things) that consciousness is a fundamental property.
I believe that, whatever else is going on with Chalmers, consciousness cannot possibly be a fundamental property of anything.

Now read the Wikipedia entry on David Chalmers and the one on philosophical zombies

Reading Questions
According to Chalmers, what must a successful theory do?
According to Chalmers, how must it do this thing?
What is a “fundamental property?”
How do physicists deal with fundamental properties?
What do physicists show about these properties?
What does Chalmers believe that philosophy of mind must face up to?

(You can ignore all the stuff about “property dualism.” It really doesn’t help here. Start again at the words “According to Chalmers.”)

According to Chalmers, what will happen once we have stated those laws?
According to Chalmers, what exists without those laws?

Now, do you agree with Chalmers that consciousness is a fundamental property? Why or why not?

What do you think of Chalmers’ argument?

Calculate your paper price

Pages(550 words)

Approximate price:-

Why Choose Our Assignment Writing Services

Quality Assignment Papers

We aim at 100% customer satisfaction. As such, we never compromise on the quality of our assignment services. Our homework helpers craft each paper carefully to match the requirements on the instruction form.

Professional Homework Helpers

We receive many applications from writers around the world daily. Nevertheless, we only choose the cream of the crop to tackle your “help with homework” requests. Hence, our homework helpers are highly-qualified individuals who maintain our quality policy.

Affordable Homework Help

We maintain a fair pricing policy for all our homework help services. Our pricing system generates quotations based on the requirements of each paper.

On-Time Assignment Delivery

At My Homework Writers, we guarantee all students swift delivery of their assignments. We understand that time is an essential factor in the academic world. We, therefore, ensure that all assignments are delivered on or before the agreed deadline.

100% Original Assignment Papers

We maintain a zero-plagiarism policy in all our essay papers. Our assignment writers stick to the students’ instructions to deliver plagiarism-free papers. We are also keen to avoid any chance of similarities with previously written papers.

24/7 Customer Support

We understand that you might run into trouble once in a while when working with our system. In the event that you do run into trouble, please get in touch with our support agents and they will immediately provide you with assistance.

Feel free to contact us via the Chat window or email: support@myhomeworkwriters.com.

How myhomeworkwriters works?

Follow these simple steps to get your homework done

1). Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

2). Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

3). Track Progress

You will be able to track the progress of your paper from our system.

4). Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Calculate the price of your order

You will get a personal manager and a discount.
We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:
$0.00

Our Assignment Writing Services

Myhomeworkwriters website holds a reputation for providing high-quality assignment writing services. You only need to give us all the requirements for your “do my homework” order, and our homework paper writers will give you the best results.

Essay Writing Services

We have highly qualified essay writers to assist you whenever you place in "help with my homework" order. Our essay writing service is designed to help students get good grades.

Admission Essay Writing service

Our admission essay writing help will assist you to secure a position at your desired learning institution. We will help you craft a top-notch personal statement paper. Our writers who know how to write a college admission essay will help you get the college admission you are longing for.

Editing and Proofreading

Our team of professional editors will help you organize your paper, paraphrase it, and eliminate any possible mistakes. Also, we will help you check on plagiarism to ensure that your final paper possesses quality and originality.

Technical papers

My homeworkwriters harbors specialists who can handle your technical papers order. Our “write my homework” services cover all academic areas you can think of. The simplicity or complexity of the paper does not affect the quality of assignment writing services.